In this guide
Key takeaways
- Victron rates its LiFePO4 batteries at 2,500 cycles at 80% DoD, versus 400 cycles at 80% DoD for its AGM batteries.
- Lead-acid makers like Trojan generally recommend using only 20–50% of capacity per cycle, so lead-acid banks are sized about twice as large.
- On those ratings, LiFePO4 at 80% DoD delivers roughly 6–7× the lifetime energy of AGM at 50% DoD.
- Lead-acid suffers when solar leaves it partly charged; LiFePO4 tolerates partial charge and is more efficient.
- Standard LiFePO4 shouldn't charge below about 25°F, so cold sheds need heated batteries or lead-acid kept fully charged.
The battery is usually the most expensive part of a solar kit, and it's the part most likely to need replacing. That makes the chemistry decision a big one. You'll hear that lithium "lasts ten times longer" or that lead-acid is "the cheap option," and both claims skip the details that decide the answer for your setup. How deep you discharge, how often the battery reaches full charge, how cold it gets and how much maintenance you'll actually do all change the math. This guide compares lithium iron phosphate (LiFePO4) with the three common lead-acid types using published manufacturer and Battery University data, so you can see where each one wins.
The three chemistries you'll actually see
"Lead-acid" covers more than one battery. For solar kits you'll mostly see two lead-acid types alongside lithium iron phosphate:
LiFePO4 (LFP)
Lithium iron phosphate cells (3.2V nominal each) with a built-in battery management system. Sealed, no watering, light for its capacity.
AGM and gel
Valve-regulated lead-acid batteries. No watering, low gassing, and widely available.
Flooded
The traditional deep-cycle battery (golf-cart style). It needs regular watering and ventilation, but tolerates rough charging and is easy to service.
Each one can work in a solar kit. The question is which one fits the way you'll charge and discharge it, and how long you want it to last.
Cycle life and depth of discharge: the core trade-off
Depth of discharge (DoD) is how much of the battery's rated capacity you use before recharging. Using 50 Ah from a 100 Ah battery is 50% DoD. For every chemistry, shallower cycles mean more of them before the battery wears out, but the size of that effect differs enormously between lithium and lead-acid.
Manufacturer datasheets are the most reliable place to see it, because they state the test conditions. Here are the published figures from Victron Energy's datasheets for its own LiFePO4, AGM and gel batteries:
| Depth of discharge | Victron LiFePO4 Smart | Victron AGM Deep Cycle | Victron Gel Deep Cycle |
|---|---|---|---|
| 80% | 2,500 cycles | 400 cycles | 500 cycles |
| 70% | 3,000 cycles | — | — |
| 50% | 5,000 cycles | 600 cycles | 750 cycles |
| 30% | — | 1,500 cycles | 1,800 cycles |
The LiFePO4 figures are rated to the point where capacity is still at least 80% of nominal. Battery University's overview of lithium chemistries lists LiFePO4 cycle life as "2,000 and higher," depending on depth of discharge and temperature.
These are one manufacturer's ratings for its own products. Other brands use different test conditions, and some don't publish cycle-life conditions at all. Treat a cycle-life number without a stated DoD and end-of-life capacity as marketing, not a spec.
What lead-acid makers recommend
Trojan Battery, a long-established deep-cycle lead-acid maker, generally recommends discharging 20–50% of rated capacity. Its user guide sets a firm ceiling: do not discharge to more than 80% DoD, as a safety factor against over-discharge damage. In practice that means a lead-acid bank is usually sized about twice as large as the energy you plan to use each day.
Lifetime energy: a fairer way to compare
Cycle counts alone can mislead because a "cycle" means different things at different depths. A better comparison is lifetime throughput: how much energy the battery delivers before it's worn out, as a multiple of its rated capacity.
Lifetime throughput ≈ rated cycles × depth of discharge
Using the Victron figures above:
| Battery and usage | Math | Throughput (× rated capacity) |
|---|---|---|
| LiFePO4 at 80% DoD | 2,500 × 0.80 | 2,000× |
| LiFePO4 at 50% DoD | 5,000 × 0.50 | 2,500× |
| Gel at 50% DoD | 750 × 0.50 | 375× |
| AGM at 50% DoD | 600 × 0.50 | 300× |
| AGM at 30% DoD | 1,500 × 0.30 | 450× |
On these ratings, a LiFePO4 battery used at 80% DoD delivers roughly 6–7 times the lifetime energy of a same-size AGM battery used at 50% DoD.
Turning that into cost per usable kWh
You can run the same math with real prices on the day you shop:
Cost per lifetime kWh = price ÷ (rated kWh × cycles × DoD)
With those throughput multiples, a LiFePO4 battery could cost several times more than an AGM of the same nameplate capacity and still come out cheaper per kWh delivered over its life, if you actually use those cycles. That last condition matters, and it's covered below.
Cycle ratings assume good conditions. Heat, chronic undercharging and calendar aging can end a battery's life before it reaches its rated cycles, especially lead-acid in a solar system that rarely gets a full charge.
Charging behavior in a solar system
Solar charging is irregular. Some days the battery reaches 100%, many days it doesn't. That pattern suits the two chemistries very differently.
Lead-acid wants a full charge, often
Battery University explains that lead-acid batteries need a regular topping charge, and that repeatedly skipping it leads to sulfation and a gradual loss of capacity. Victron's LiFePO4 datasheet makes the same point from the other side: lead-acid batteries operated in a chronic deficit fail prematurely from sulfation. A week of cloudy weather in a solar-only cabin is exactly that deficit.
Lead-acid also slows down near full. Victron notes that lead-acid charging becomes inefficient above roughly 80% state of charge, with efficiencies of 50% or less in solar systems at that stage. You need extra panel capacity or long sunny afternoons to finish the job.
LiFePO4 is comfortable partly charged
LiFePO4 doesn't need to reach full charge to stay healthy, according to Victron, and its round-trip efficiency is listed at 92% versus about 80% for an average lead-acid battery. More of each day's solar harvest ends up as usable energy, which can let you get by with fewer panels.
| Charging factor | LiFePO4 | AGM / gel | Flooded |
|---|---|---|---|
| Round-trip efficiency (Victron figures) | About 92% | About 80% (average lead-acid) | |
| Partial state of charge | Tolerated | Causes sulfation if chronic | |
| Equalizing | Not used | Never (per Trojan) | Periodically (per Trojan) |
| Charge profile | Lithium/LFP setting required | AGM or gel setting | Flooded setting |
Whatever you choose, your charge controller and inverter-charger must support that chemistry's charge profile. Check this before buying, especially when switching an existing system from lead-acid to lithium.
Temperature, maintenance and safety
Cold
This is lead-acid's quiet advantage. Battle Born Batteries says LiFePO4 batteries can generally discharge down to about −4°F but should not be charged below about 25°F unless they have internal heating; the BMS blocks charging outside safe limits. Victron's datasheet lists a charging range of +5°C to +50°C (41°F to 122°F).
Lead-acid can charge in the cold, but it has its own risk. Trojan warns that batteries can freeze below 32°F if they aren't fully charged. Trojan also notes that heat shortens battery life even as it raises capacity, so neither chemistry likes an uninsulated shed in summer.
Maintenance
- Flooded: Trojan says to water periodically (check new batteries every few weeks to learn the interval), add water only after a full charge, and equalize periodically. Charge in a ventilated area with vent caps secured, and wear eye protection and acid-resistant gloves.
- AGM and gel: Never add water and never equalize, per Trojan. They gas far less than flooded batteries, but Trojan still advises charging in a ventilated area.
- LiFePO4: No watering or equalizing. The BMS handles cell protection, so buy batteries with documented BMS limits.
Storage
For seasonal cabins, lead-acid needs attention over the off-season. Trojan recommends recharging stored batteries when they drop to about 70% state of charge (flooded) or 75% (AGM/gel). Battery University says to recharge every six months in storage, or every 6–12 months for AGM.
Safety
Battery University describes LiFePO4 as having good thermal stability, listing a thermal runaway threshold of about 270°C (518°F). That is a key reason it became the default lithium chemistry for home and RV storage. Any battery can deliver dangerous short-circuit current, though, so fuse it properly; see our Class T fuse guide.
Which should you buy?
LiFePO4 is the right default for most new solar kits that get used regularly. Lead-acid still has honest use cases. Here's how we'd decide:
| Your situation | Better fit | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Cabin, van or off-grid shed used weekly or daily | LiFePO4 | High lifetime throughput, tolerates partial charge, higher efficiency |
| Battery lives where it's often below freezing, no heat | Heated LiFePO4, or lead-acid kept charged | Standard LFP shouldn't charge below about 25°F |
| Rarely used backup that sits on float | AGM can be reasonable | Few cycles means LiFePO4's cycle advantage matters less |
| Tight upfront budget, willing to maintain | Flooded | Lower entry cost; needs watering, ventilation and equalizing |
| Expanding an existing lead-acid bank | Replace rather than mix | Different chemistries need different charge settings |
- Find the cycle-life rating with its DoD and end-of-life capacity on the datasheet
- Calculate cost per lifetime kWh with today's prices
- Confirm your controller and inverter-charger have the right charge profile
- Check the low-temperature charging limit against where the battery will live
- For lead-acid, plan for ventilation (flooded) and off-season charging
Frequently asked questions
How many cycles does a LiFePO4 battery last compared with lead-acid?
It depends on depth of discharge and the specific product. Victron's datasheets rate its LiFePO4 batteries at 2,500 cycles at 80% depth of discharge and 5,000 at 50%, while its AGM deep-cycle batteries are rated at 400 cycles at 80% and 600 at 50%. Battery University lists LiFePO4 at 2,000 cycles and higher depending on conditions.
How deep can I discharge a lead-acid solar battery?
Trojan Battery generally recommends discharging 20 to 50% of rated capacity and advises never going beyond 80% depth of discharge. Shallower cycles give more cycles, which is why lead-acid banks are usually sized about twice as large as daily use.
Is LiFePO4 worth the higher price for a solar kit?
For a system you cycle regularly, usually yes. Divide the price by rated kWh × cycles × depth of discharge to get cost per lifetime kWh. Using Victron's ratings, LiFePO4 delivers several times the lifetime energy of AGM, so it can cost more upfront and still be cheaper per kWh delivered, as long as you actually use those cycles.
Can I charge a LiFePO4 battery in freezing weather?
Not a standard one. Battle Born Batteries says LiFePO4 shouldn't be charged below about 25°F without internal heating, and the BMS blocks charging outside safe limits. Discharging is usually possible down to about −4°F. Heated batteries or an insulated battery space solve this.
Do sealed AGM batteries need maintenance?
Much less than flooded batteries. Trojan says never to add water to or equalize AGM and gel batteries. They still need the correct charge profile, regular full charges to avoid sulfation, and periodic recharging in storage.
Match the battery to the whole kit
Our kit buying guide covers what complete kits include, which battery types they ship with, and how to check that the controller and inverter support your chemistry.
Read the kit buying guide →Sources
- 12.8V Lithium Iron Phosphate Batteries Smart: Datasheet — Victron Energy
- GEL and AGM Batteries: Datasheet — Victron Energy
- BU-205: Types of Lithium-ion — Battery University
- BU-403: Charging Lead Acid — Battery University
- Battery User's Guide — Trojan Battery Company
- Understanding Temperature Limits of LiFePO4 Batteries — Battle Born Batteries
This guide is for general information only and is not electrical, engineering or legal advice. Always follow the manufacturer's instructions, the National Electrical Code (NFPA 70) as adopted in your area, and local permitting rules, and hire a licensed electrician where your jurisdiction requires one. Product availability, specs and prices change; verify them on the listing before you buy. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.